Best Primer for Oily Skin

best primer for oily skin

We want to make sure that you are using the best primer for oily skin.

It will help your makeup to stay in place and look great.

We looked at 27 primers for oily skin and covered more than 112 hours of research and testing to create this review in which we recommend that the e.l.f Mineral Infused Face Primer stood out as the best primer for oily skin to buy. Our decision was based on the primer’s ability to control oil and shine on the skin, how long it lasts, and the value for the money. It is hard to find makeup that will work with oily skin and will not lead to additional breakouts.

Top Pick

1. e.l.f Mineral Infused Face Primer

This formula is great for oily skin and people with large pores. It will allow the skin to have a flawless look. It will help to reduce the appearance of the pores and will minimize their appearance. There will be a satin finish that will last all day. This is a very good thing. There will be no need to reapply the formula at any point during the day.

This product was tested by us, our consumer product testers and professionals in the makeup industry and is the best foundation primers for oily skin. It is silicone based and will help reduce the appearance of pores. Silicone is recommended to be used with oily skin as it will not add more oil to the face. It has a moderate price but if used often this product can get to be expensive, but this is high quality and is definetly worth the price.

Who should get this

A primer should be the first step for anyone when they are applying their makeup. The primer is needed for everyone but especially for people with oily skin types. If you feel that you do not need a primer you are going to have to rethink this. Primers come in different forms. They can come in creams, gels, and powders. They can be used before the foundation and before using a tinted moisturizer. If the skin is properly prepared, the makeup will stay on all day without having to be reapplied. This is great for people with both oily and other types of skin also. A primer will help reduce the size of the pores and reduce the appearance of wrinkles as well as fine lines. Some of them can help correct uneven skin tones. It will allow for better makeup coverage as well.

Our other top picks

If you like products that will last long and have a satin finish you will like that there is a product that will help keep the face moisturized and allow the skin to be soft at the same time. Baby Skin Instant Pore Eraser is made by Maybelline New York and has some great features. It will reduce the size of the pores and will give the face a smooth finish.

The Shine Killer by NYX will give the face a matte look. It will help reduce shine and can be worn alone or under makeup. This product will also prevent the makeup from melting due to the oil on the skin.

If you are looking for a formula that is lightweight try Revlon’s Photoready Perfecting Primer. This will help even out skin tone as well. This can also be worn by itself. No other makeup products are needed. While they can be worn they are not required for a finished and well put together look.

The Thank Me Later Eye Primer is made by Elizabeth Mott. This formula is lightweight and waterproof. It will help the makeup on the eye last longer and will stop creasing. This is great for people that have oily skin even area their eyes and surrounding areas.

How we selected

If you have oily skin wearing makeup, especially a powder foundation can be frustrating. Due to the excessive amounts of oil the makeup will almost melt into the skin. This makes it hard to have a polished and clean look. Wearing makeup with oily skin is not impossible. People that have oily skin should look for primers that are silicone based. This helps fill in the larger pores. It was also important to find a primer that is lightweight. Clogged pores are a problem for people with oily skin, but the best face wash for oily skin and the best facial toners can help.

A heavy formula can only make this problem worse. Primers for oily skin should have a finish that is matte. If you are not sure how the primer is going to dry be sure to test a little bit on the back of your hand before making a purchase. The formula should be able to dry and not leave behind a shiny or a greasy feeling. People that have oily skin should not use primers that leave the skin dewy or have an illuminating finish as this will add to the shiny appearance of your skin, so these were removed during the selection phase.

How we tested them

We started to match the pore minimizing primers to a cross section of our consumers, in terms of their sex, age, lifestyle, skin type and whether they used a primer currently. Then we sent out the primers for them to test for us, and also got them ready for ourselves.  Once everyone had their primers in hand we started by completing the basic statistics for them, such as the pack size, and contanier type, texture and of course, the ingredients.

Then, before we got started on using the products, we each had to test a small patch of our skin to check it was safe to use the primers. Once that was done, the instructions for the test was simple to follow, to use the primer and to monitor how they worked for us with a final score when we had finished using them. So, armed with the primers, we incorporated them into our daily beauty routines and monitored our skin reactions.

Once we had finished testing (which took months to complete), all of the scorecards were back in and we waited to find out the results of which ones came out on top.  Oily skin can be a real pain. If you think makeup alone will fix the skin you are wrong. Wearing makeup can make oily skin worse. Oily can give makeup the appearance that it is melting. You will end up with a messy and unfinished look. That is why foundation primers were made and they can help out a great deal. Our pick for the best primer for people with oily skin ise.l.f Mineral Infused Face Primer. It is very lightweight and can also give the face an oil free and matte look when finished applying it. This formula does not contain fragrances that can irritate the skin especially sensitive skin. This formula is affordable to use. It is an essential product that should be part of the daily makeup routine. We found our favorite picks were not always the more expensive ones.

Full Foundation Primers for Oily Skin Reviews

2. Maybelline New York Baby Skin Instant Pore Eraser

This is a must have for people with greasy and shiny skin. It is a lightweight formula and will leave the skin feeling soft with a matte finish. It will reduce the appearance or pores and can be used without a moisturizer. This product can be used alone or it can be used with additional makeup products. This product is inexpensive and is free from fragrances. It is non comedogenic and will not add extra oil to the skin to clog the pores. This is great for people with oily skin as they already have issues with clogged pores. The primer is made with Propylene glycol and Dimethicone crosspolymer. This will allow it to both moisturize and protect the skin. This primer can be used to protect the skin from the harsh environments that the face is up against every day. It can be used to protect the skin from poor air quality and other impurities that are found in the air.

The good
Reasonably priced
Free of fragrances
Has a matte finish
There is added moisturizer

The bad
Does not look finished without additional makeup
Can be hard to blend foundation in

3. NYX Shine Killer

This primer is great for oily skin because it will work for the entire day. This can be worn without makeup for people that do not like to put too much on their face. It can be applied at the beginning of the day and you will not have to apply anything else to your face. The product sells quickly on the NYX website. It is a product that is in high demand. The product goes quickly. The primer leaves a matte finish and will not come off even with physical activity such as workout out. Women have worn this makeup to the gym and it was still perfect on the face even after they have finished working out.
It is fragrance free and is light on the skin.

The good
Has a matte finish
Free of fragrances
Lightweight formula

The bad
Product is expensive
May not work for all users

4. Revlon Photoready Perfecting Primer

This is one of the best products found in the drugstore for people with oily skin. It is able to reflect the light and hide imperfections on the skin. There is a pint tint to this primer which is helpful to people with skin discoloration or uneven skin tone. At first the product may look like it is turning the skin pink but it will become transparent once it sets. This can be used by people with any skin tone as the pink will go away. This is also good for people that have sensitive skin. It is free from parabens, fragrances, and talc. This will reduce the amount of oil that is used on the skin.

The good
Affordable to use
Has a bottle with a pump
Has a matte finish

The bad
May lead to breakouts
May have a cakey appearance

5. Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Primer

This product is used on the eye. It was designed to keep eyeshadow from caking up and creasing. It is great for oily skin. This product is also lightweight and waterproof. The product is expensive but a little bit can go a long way. A bottle can last for a long period of time. Only a very small amount is needed on the eyelids. A little bit of this eye primer will go a long way.
The formula has a silky feel to it. It will dry transparent and will prepare the eyelids for the application of eyeshadow. This will help the shadow stay on the lids for a longer period of time. It will also intensify the color of the shadow and allow the eyes to really stand out.

The good
Free from fragrances
Not tested on animals
A sample can be requested before making a purchase

The bad
Expensive to purchase

How to Keep Makeup Lasting Longer

Oily skin can be hard to work with when applying makeup. You may spend an hour doing your makeup to have it run in as little as 30 minutes. This can get very annoying.

Here are some tips to control oil and allow the makeup to last longer from the experts

  1. It is important to start with a freshly washed face. This will help reduce the amount of oil that is on the skin.
  2. A toner with oil control should also be used to help reduce the shine.
  3. Be sure to select the right care products for the skin. Do not use moisturizers that contain a lot of oil. Select products that are water based or gel formulas when applying makeup.
  4. Do not apply creams directly to the eyelids when wearing eyeshadow. The creams can cause the shadow to break apart.
  5. Be sure to blot on the makeup. Use blotting paper instead of a power. This will reduce the clump appearance.
  6. A primer is very important for oily skin. If you are not using a primer you should be.
  7. Look for cosmetic products that will last for a long time. If the formula is not deigned to be long lasting it will break down in a short period of time.
  8. Look for formulas that are waterproof. They can help keep the makeup on the eyes and prevent it from running off.
    A good power should be applied after the makeup. The baking method if a good technique to use for this purpose.

Additional sources

  1. R Arbuckle. Patient experiences with oily skin
  2. Y Takagi. International Journal of Clinical Dermatology & Research
  3. Researchgate. The effects of a daily facial oily skin