Best Ice Tray Sets for your Freezer

best ice trays reviews

The best ice trays…..such a simple piece of kitchenware.

But still vital enough to annoy anyone who doesn’t have one.

Ice cube molds and trays are essential for a hot summer day when all you need is an instantly chilled drink.

Every week there are claims from companies that they have the best ice trays, and that they are far better quality and retain freezing temperatures for longer.

Well….we have researched and tested the best ice tray sets so you can choose the one that suits your usage and budget needs best.

We looked at 31 different ice tray sets and moulds covering more than 63 hours of research and testing to write these ice tray reviews which lead us to recommend that the OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Tray stands out as the best ice tray to buy for most people. This ice tray comes with a plastic lid that seals up as soon as it comes in contact with water and has great half-moon shaped slots, that allow the cubes to be pushed out easily with a gentle nudge.

Top Pick:

1. OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray with Lid

OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Tray
  • Performance
  • Settings/Features
  • Ease of Use
  • Durability


Price: $10
Buy Now

We were very much impressed with these innovative ice cube trays. The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Tray accomplishes exactly what it claims in its name. The ice tray came with a great plastic lid that seals up as soon as it comes in contact with water; this ensures a spill free environment, perfect when you’re in a hurry. We tried several angles before finally approving the “sealant” feature of this tray. The ice tray comes with 100% lifetime warranty which means if at any point your product fails to perform, you’ll get a free replacement.

Why our reviews are trustworthy

We have covered ice cube trays here at for a few years now and have logged countless hours of research and testing. We’ve looked at a large number of different types of ice trays, from cool ice molds, sphere ice trays, unique ice trays and large ice trays to create this review each year. We always keep up with reviews from other noteworthy companies that also test or review products, such as, Consumer Reports, Amazon and Which? though we do find sometimes that the coverage is not as comprehensive as it could be. Then we do our own testing by selecting our participating experts, ourselves and members of our consumer product testing groups to provide their feedback through our product testing panels.

*This review covers the best ice trays on the market before and since the last time we created this guide.

How we began the test selection process

We started by making a list of all of the best ice trays sets that we could find for sale in retailers stores and online. We listed 31 ice trays in the original selection process for this category.

We combed through thousands of reviews to be able to bring you the most helpful, insightful information on the best ice trays available. And there are so many variables to get right: the material, the tray size (12, 14 or 16), and lids. There are countless styles of ice cube trays out there, making water into every size and shape of ice imaginable.

We found in our research that covered ice cube trays are great for keeping smells out, but some designs worked better than others, however, they all succeeded in preventing spilling when being moved from the sink to the freezer after filling. The best covered ice trays not only stops spills and keeping smells out, but also allow the tray to be stored at an angle. When stacked, an ice tray with a lid also keeps the tops of the ice cube shapes clean if you stack other things on top.

We were then able to whittle the list down to the 13 ice trays we brought in for testing to see if they make perfect ice cubes.

How we tested them

We wanted to see if there were any major differences in cooling or melt rate based on the ice cube shapes (square, round, half-moon, rectangular) and surface area of the unique ice cubes with the 13 trays we were testing. We knew from previous years testing that large ice cube molds the slower they melt so this years, but we really wanted to see if there were any major differences in cooling or melt rate based on shape alone.

To do this, we poured 15ml of water per mold in each of the 13 unique ice cube trays and then waited while they froze overnight. The next morning, we added three ice cubes from each tray to 300ml of room temperature water in glasses (ones that we were looking at for another review); the total weight of the ice cubes was around 54 grams (18 grams per cube).

The results of the test revealed that the shape of the ice cube shapes at this size doesn’t make a substantial difference to how quickly or slowly it melts. So we concluded our testing by looking at the other areas of interest and scoring them all accordingly.

Each panelist then selected their top rated ice cube trays before comparing the prices of each and coming up with the overall winner with the most picks.

The Runners Up:

2. Sterilite 72508006 White BPA Free Ice Cube Bin

Price: $7
Buy Now

Looking for a large ice cube tray? Well, this is the answer. Sterilite brings a series of great ice cube molds that can serve whole blocks of ice. When we got our hands one of the unique ice trays for our testing purposes, we thought it may occupy a lot of space in our freezer but once we actually placed it there, we found it to be very space savvy. The large ice cube mold is completely dishwasher safe and is a great way to dispense ice for whole needs like hosting a party or making ice for a beer bin for summer barbecues.

3. Chillz Ice Ball Maker Mold – Black Flexible Silicone Ice Tray 

Price: $9
Buy Now

Looking for an ice tray that gives you the best value for money? Then choose the Chillz Ice Ball Maker Mold. Not only do these sphere ice cube mold will give you cool ice cubes but they offer superior protection against BPA. We were very much delighted to freeze our first ice cube spheres, roughly 4×4.5.  Later on we found out that ice in the form of spheres melt a little slower, another advantage of this round ice mold. The ice tray itself was very flexible, yet sturdy. We tried pulling and flexing it in all directions but it remained as is. On top of this, the ice tray is dishwasher friendly so if you have something other than ice in mind, this one’s for you.

4. Kitch Easy Release White Ice Cube Tray

Price: $10
Buy Now

As simple as it gets, these ice cube molds come in packs of 4 and stick to the purpose they were built for. Before we put them under our testing procedure we were keen to find out the materials used in making these shaped ice trays. Everything was top notch and approved by the FDA.  Each of these unique ice cube trays can store 16 cubes of ice, which means a total of 64 cubes. The design itself is quite flexible and the trays can withstand a couple of hard impacts before giving in.

5. Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds 

Price: $11
Buy Now

This is another cleverly designed large ice cube tray. Not exactly a tray, the sphere ice cube molds can provide you with ice in spherical form much like the tray mentioned earlier. At first we thought of good reasons as to why someone would want round ice cubes but after we tried this product we were happy to have one for ourselves. The reasons were simple; for only $11 you can add color & style to your beverage or drink. The spheres measure 2.5″ in diameter and come with a silicon seal to make sure the shaped ice cubes do not lose their originality as a result of accidental splashing.

6. Arctic Chill Large Ice Cube Tray, 2 Pack 

Price: $13
Buy Now

These are one of the best ice trays if size really matters for you! When we got these ice trays for testing and reviewing, the first impression we got was refreshing. The unique ice cube tray design is quite aesthetic, even though simple. The primary function, i.e. freezing ice works flawlessly thanks to the silicon layered trays that prevent the cubes from spilling or melting too quickly. The cool ice cube tray can be used for other purposes as well, like freezing sweets, juices, or whatever you like. It’s worth mentioning that the ice trays have been approved by the FDA and free of any BPA.

7. ChefLand Easy Release No Spill Ice Cube Tray with Removable Cover 

Price: $9
Buy Now

This is one of the best ice cube trays on the market. For $10, you get two good ice trays. While testing these, we found them to be spot-on not just because of the general design but because of the innovative features alongside the main one. The ice tray comes with a fast release mechanism that makes the process of actually acquiring an ice cube out of the tray painless to get perfect ice cubes. The custom lid in the meantime preserves the purity of the ice cubes and keeps them clean each time you take them out of the freezer.

8. Lucentee Silly Ice Cube Trays Candy Molds

Price: $9
Buy Now

These are unique ice cube trays that feature an absolutely brilliant design. Out of all the trays we reviewed, we found this one to be cool, attractive and playful. We experimented a lot on these cool ice trays and really love them. In addition to freezing ice we tried making some candy as well. The process was very much simple and the end product quite fun given the unique ice cube shapes embedded within each tray.

9. BNYD Easy Push Pop out round Mini Ice Cube Trays

Price: $9
Buy Now

You would think that there’s a limit to how much innovative a company can be to create shaped ice cube trays but apparently there’s always something new in the market that out dates an existing product. The BNYD Easy Push Pop ice tray is one of these products. As the name says it all, the cool ice trays can ease the entire process of actually taking the ice cube out. We tried it and we loved it. We very much agree with the fact that freezing ice isn’t a problem, but sometimes taking it out can result in a painful process. With this ice tray we were able to get the cool ice cubes out with a single push, no sweat, no mess!

10. Rubbermaid 2 Pack Ice Cube Tray

Price: $7
Buy Now

Pack of 2, 16 cubes each. 32 ice cubes for only $7, sounds like a good deal. And it is. This is an affordable ice tray pack that does what you expect from it, but don’t let its dull colors fool you. We were impressed by the soft silicone material used in its fabrication. Everything was certified by the FDA, meaning there was absolutely no BPA to worry about. The surface of the rubber ice trays were non-stick that made it a whole lot easier to perform cleaning compared to other trays that tend to hold everything in.

11. Candy Molds & Ice Cube Trays Hearts, Stars and Shells

Price: $7
Buy Now

This is a package deal and not a single product. In addition to getting a set of cool ice trays, you get ice cube molds as well which you can use to make candy or freeze any other liquid. The molds were very “cute” but we were sure not to judge a book by its cover. We performed an in dept analysis of the material used to make the ice trays and molds; we were satisfied with the quality of the materials, especially when we were assured there was no BPA, whatsoever. The cool ice cube trays were not just easy to use, but they were easy to clean as well. The non-stick element was at play here and a single wash in the dishwasher was enough to purify it of all unwanted particles.

12. Cubette Mini Ice Cube Trays

Price: $6
Buy Now

Sometimes, quantity is much more important than the size of the product. If that’s your need then choose these ice trays. The Cubette Mini Ice Cube Trays from Better Houseware are a great way to treat a plethora of guests at parties. Each unique ice cube tray had 90 vacancies, which were more than enough to indulge our entire product testing panel! The shaped ice cube tray design is very ergonomic as well and a small application of force is all that’s needed to release the cubes.

13. Ice Cube Trays-Ice Trays with No-Spill Cover

Price: $12
Buy Now

Made out of FDA approved materials, the ice cube molds are great for all your ice tray needs. We found the covered ice cube tray itself as well as the accessories very useful when it came to scooping and removing the perfect ice cubes. The diversion slot design, or as it is called prevented any excessive spill while the quantity of cubes was enough to satisfy the price tag.

Additional Sources: